Coalition Promotes Two
Equal Tracks for Interior Department Bison
A March 4 Department of Interior News Release, based on Secretary
Haaland’s Order 3410, describes a new federal commitment to restore
“wild and healthy” populations of bison on American grasslands.
It states that Native American led opportunities to establish new
large herds owned or managed by Tribes will be centrally prioritized.
A “shared stewardship plan” is described in 3410. As presented,
shared stewardship implies co-management and some degree of
co-control of public bison with Tribes. Unfortunately, “wild and
healthy” are not defined, and neither the news release nor 3410
recognize laws mandating Interior to restore truly wild public-trust
bison in National Parks and Refuges, and these documents do not
acknowledge almost certain conflicts between these obligations and
Tribal goals.
As background, a misrepresentation of 19th century bison
history occurs in the news release and in 3410. The complicated
eradication and near extinction of bison is presented emphasizing a
“U. S. policy” intended to “harm and control” Tribes that
depended upon bison. This oversimplification of history is common in
today’s media. In reality, bison were near-eradicated for several
reasons including commercial harvests as well as to “control”
Tribes. Both Euro-Americans and Native Americans participated, though
not always equally or for the same purposes. A selective, biased
presentation of 19th century history should not be used to
justify exceptional access to public bison for Tribes today. A more
complete and authentic history would recognize our common humanity
and be less divisive in today’s world. We cannot heal what we do
not reveal.
Today, plains bison exist in private commercial herds, in Tribal
herds, and in “conservations herds” owned by government agencies,
The Nature Conservancy or by American Prairie. Only 13 herds are
fully controlled by the Department of Interior. For plains bison in
the USA, the most important conservation issue is the long-practiced
and continuing domestication of bison with loss of wild genetics.
Restoration and maintenance of wildness in bison requires a large
herd to forestall effects of genetic drift, minimizing artificial
selection practices, and maximizing natural selective forces, to the
extent practicable. (See elsewhere on this website under the toolbar
“Why Wildness”.) Most bison herds are small and subject to some,
usually a lot of, artificial selection. Domestication is most
pronounced in commercial herds containing the vast majority of plains
bison. For bison in the USA, only 13 federal herds within National
Parks and Wildlife Refuges have a reliable mandate, in the law, to
restore and maintain wildness. These herds are critical to the future
wildness of our plains bison.
The Department of Interior has dual obligations for bison management
– centered in its Bureau of Indian Affairs, the National Park
Service and the Fish & Wildlife Service. Tribal goals vary among
tribes and have varied with time, as indicated by the limited but
consistent information available for current Tribally-owned herds.
Tribal goals appropriately emphasize Tribal nutrition and economic
development, with management for abundant production. This emphasizes
artificial selection that is not compatible with National Park and
Federal Refuge mandates for wildness.
Today, 63 Tribes own over 20,000 bison (Intertribal Buffalo Council
website). Almost all these herds are small such that genetic drift
augments preponderant artificial selection. This compares to only 13
federal herds with about 10,000 bison. Only 2 of these federal herds
have at least 1000 bison, possibly sufficient to forestall effects of
genetic drift in weakening natural selection.
Despite the above disparity and the overwhelming threat of
domestication to plains bison, Haaland’s news release and 3410
emphasize support for more Tribal bison, including “shared
stewardship” and “prioritizing Tribal led opportunities” to
enhance bison on federal lands. Mandates of the Department of
Interior emphasizing natural selection that is not compatible with
major Tribal goals requiring artificial management are relegated
largely to an appendix of 3410. The stark inadequacy of Interior’s
few, mostly small, bison herds to avoid further domestication is not
mentioned.
The Charles M. Russell National Wildlife Refuge lies in the center of
this disparity. It is the largest federal refuge within the historic
range of plains bison. It has no bison, despite decades of efforts to
promote restoration. It is the most obvious federal opportunity to
establish a “large, wide-ranging bison herd subject to the forces
of natural selection, where their role as ecosystem engineers shapes
healthy and diverse ecological communities (Section 3,f; appendix to
4310). The Refuge Improvement Act (1997) provides a clear mandate for
this important goal. Tribal co-management may be illegal and would
threaten the necessity to minimize artificial management for bison
production on the CMR.
The Bison Coalition has supported a two-track approach to achieving
the goals of Haaland’s bison initiative. (See NEWS, August 11 and
21, 2021, this website.) We should support Tribal bison for Tribal
needs on Tribal lands; but the critical status of federal bison, with
but 2 large herds to save wild bison genomes, and Congressional
mandates for the Park Service and for Federal Refuges, dictate a
separate management track focused on bison wildness.
(Possible introduction of wild bison on BLM or Forest Service lands,
likely under state management, is not addressed here. It will be
politically difficult; but could occur based on Tribal political
support. The subject of Tribal co-management of such bison on federal
multiple-use lands is beyond the scope of these comments. Any devil
would be in the details to be negotiated.)